How we tested
We spent three weeks living with each service on a Roku Ultra, a Fire TV Stick 4K and an NVIDIA Shield. We looked at four things that matter in daily use: the depth and freshness of the catalog, the quality of the apps, what you actually get at the advertised price, and whether 4K HDR works reliably. Prices below are US monthly rates at the time of writing.
Quick comparison
| Service | Best for | Price | 4K HDR | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Netflix Top pick | Overall catalog | $15.49–$22.99 | Yes | 9.2 / 10 |
| Prime Video | Value / sports | $8.99 or included | Yes | 8.7 / 10 |
| Max | Prestige TV | $9.99–$20.99 | Yes | 8.6 / 10 |
| Disney+ | Families | $13.99 | Yes | 8.4 / 10 |
| Hulu | Next-day TV | $9.99–$18.99 | Limited | 7.9 / 10 |
1. Netflix — Best overall
Netflix
9.2 / 10Still the service everything else is measured against. The catalog is deep, originals arrive constantly, and the app is fast and consistent on nearly every device. The ad-supported tier is a reasonable way to cut costs if you can tolerate interruptions.
What we like
- Unmatched breadth and new releases
- Excellent apps on every platform
- Genuine 4K HDR on the top tier
What we don't
- Premium tier is expensive
- Catalog rotates without notice
- Ad tier still shows interruptions
2. Prime Video — Best value
Prime Video
8.7 / 10If you already pay for Amazon Prime, this is effectively free. The library is large, live sports are a real differentiator, and the interface has improved a lot. Channel add-ons can get pricey, so keep an eye on what you enable.
What we like
- Included with Prime
- Live sports and exclusive titles
- Good 4K selection
What we don't
- Confusing add-on channels
- Ads on some plans
3. Max — Best for prestige TV
For scripted television, nothing else comes close. HBO's back catalog plus the Warner Bros. library makes this the pick for anyone who cares about series over quantity. The ad-free tier is the one to get if your budget allows.
See Max plans4. Disney+ — Best for families
Strong for kids, Marvel and Star Wars fans, and the bundle with Hulu and ESPN+ is good value. Outside those franchises the catalog is narrower than Netflix's.
Get Disney+5. Hulu — Best for next-day TV
Hulu's strength is current-season network television shortly after broadcast. It's a good complement to a film-first service, but its 4K support is limited compared with the others here.
Try HuluOur verdict
There is no single service that does everything well. The sensible approach is one broad service for everyday viewing, one specialist service for the shows you love, and a rotate-on-demand strategy for everything else. Cancel and resubscribe as new seasons drop — the services are counting on you forgetting to.